Dr Andrew Bishop slams media furore

A BASINGSTOKE hospital chief believes the controversy over the Liverpool Care Pathway has affected the number of patients who are being put on the end-of-life treatment.

Speaking at a Council of Governors meeting, Dr Andrew Bishop, pictured, medical director and consultant cardiologist at Hampshire Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, was scathing about the national media furore surrounding the LCP.

Many relatives of patients who have been placed on the pathway have come forward in recent months to express their concerns. Some have claimed that their loved ones have been put on the pathway without their knowledge, and when they are not dying.

National headlines have slammed the LCP, with the Daily Mail – which has spearheaded a campaign against the practice – covering the issue in depth. One headline stated ‘60,000 patients put on death pathway without being told’, while another said: ‘Now sick babies go on death pathway’.

Mr Bishop told his fellow governors: “What’s going on publicly and in the press is poor and bad, and should not be happening.

“The number of people who die in hospital is decreasing on the Liverpool Care Pathway, and we can imagine why that is – the chatter that is going on outside.”

Mr Bishop said he had received reassurances from the palliative care team at the trust that much of the ethos behind the LCP would remain even if the pathway itself could not survive the public debate.

He said: “Happily, they (the palliative care team) think most of the values of the LCP have already become ingrained if the combination of chattering classes and vox pops does a death (to the LCP).”

Comments(5)

NHSReformGroup says...
6:48pm Wed 6 Feb 13

Seems like he's a stranger to the concept of 'patient choice'..and one of those who attempts to dismiss anyone who disagrees with him as 'stupid' or 'ignorant'...arrogan
t, that's the word isn't it?

NHSReformGroup says...
6:51pm Wed 6 Feb 13

....congratulations to Cure the NHS in exposing the MidStaffs. scandal too...just goes to show what arrogant managers and corporate doctors are capable of doing to a health service.....fantasti
c win for patients who go into hospitals expecting to be treated, not put on an End of Life Care pathway....patient choice, patient power...its OUR NHS....they are merely hired hands......do wish more patients would let them know that a bit more often!

irene ogrizek says...
12:44am Thu 7 Feb 13

We are having similar problems here in Canada. Doctors are euthanizing without consultation....no pathway, but a withdrawal of care that is less defined, which is worse. It's harder to pinpoint. I've written about my family's experience trying to save my mother after having signed a DNR. She is alive now, 4 years later, but it was a close call. http://ireneogrizek.
ca/?p=5762

Pikey-Biker says...
5:12pm Thu 7 Feb 13

NHSReformGroup wrote:
Seems like he's a stranger to the concept of 'patient choice'..and one of those who attempts to dismiss anyone who disagrees with him as 'stupid' or 'ignorant'...arrogan t, that's the word isn't it?
There are comments made about the Pathway that are simply not true, and it’s frustrating that they are stated as fact when they are not

BugBear says...
4:05pm Fri 8 Feb 13

Both my parents died in the Basingstoke Hospital and although I can't fault the care they received, in fact it was excellent, caring and considerate towards both them and my family this controversy about the Liverpool Care Pathway has unsettled us and of course now we wonder, possibly unnecessarily whether more could have been done to prolong their lives. We now say had my Mum been the Queen or my Father the Duke, would they still be alive because for us they were just as, if not more important.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree