Letters RSS Feed


Shock results on ME

ANYONE whose family has been affected by ME (Myalgic Encephalomyelitis) or chronic fatigue syndrome will not be surprised to read in the Lancet and other national media that current treatments have been found to be, at best, only moderately effective. But they will be stunned to discover that graded exercise, the therapy which patients tell us has a greater risk of causing them harm, has been rated more effective than pacing, the therapy which patients say carries least risk and does most good!

Before the National Institute for Health and Clinic Excellence jump to change its guidelines on the diagnosis and management of ME, based on this study, it must bear in mind that the specialist expertise and safeguards which apply in a controlled research environment do not apply across the NHS as a whole.

The Medical Research Council must spend the £1.5m it has earmarked for research on ME on finding the cause of this horribly disabling illness so science can find a cure.

Sir Peter Spencer, Chief Executive, Action for ME, 3rd Floor, Canningford House, 38 Victoria Street, Bristol, BS1 6BY Tel: 0117 930 1324

Comments(2)

Lilpink says...
9:58am Fri 25 Feb 11

The ME community is not so terribly stunned at the results of the PACE Trial. They had been decided upon even before the trial had begun. A complaint about almost every aspect of the trial was made to the MRC by Professor Hooper and can be seen here: http://www.meactionu
k.org.uk/magical-med
icine.pdf

Since the publication of the Trial last week we have had yet another piece of biomedical research from the US to (yet again) illustrate the organic, physical nature of this illness: http://www.cfids.org
/research/proteome-a
nalysis.pdf

I wonder how many more biomedical research papers it will take to stop the UK treating this illness as a mental illness and manipulating 'research' to push it's behavioural 'therapies' on a vulnerable population?

Peter Spencer's remarks are more than disingenuous as he represents one of only two charities who did not call for the PACE Trial to be abandoned whilst it was still in the planning stage. Had AfME removed their endorsement this waste of £5 million may not have happened and we would not have to run the gauntlet of atricles which suggest that people with this disease just need a bit of exercise and mind training!

Wingfingers says...
9:34pm Fri 25 Feb 11

Our Government has wasted millions of taxpayers' £s on this PACE trial and others, which have yielded inconclusive results. No-one with true M.E. has ever been cured with the techniques. CBT tries to teach you that you're not really ill, it’s in your head. It seems to cure AIDS and cancer patients too, doesn't it? Increasing exercise (GET) is contra-indicated in true ME as it further damages the mitochondria, worsening the condition. These trials comprised a mixed group, using a definition that actually excluded people with neurological disease (such as ME) - it should therefore be surprising to find anyone with true ME among their patients groups. These groups contain people without ME but with various depressive disorders, so you expect to see a few improve - as was found. True ME is now thought to be caused by an infectious retrovirus similar to HIV. It's a 'brain" virus, found in around 98% of true ME patients using the latest tissue culture techniques. Recent "contamination" theories have been firmly disproven. Physically disabled people can function well in an office job - but if your BRAIN is attacked, meaning that your head is always fuzzy like you have a hangover, bad flu, jet lag and have been hit by a bus all at once - you'll be very ill. Those following the events of real ME research will know that several people have been taking anti-retroviral drugs for around a year, and mostly making steady progress. It's just a matter of time before all this psycho stuff becomes water under the bridge - just as in the case of stomach ulcers, MS, and many other diseases without obvious causes. Unfortunately for sick patients, there seem to be many reactionaries putting on the brakes. If our government really wanted to get all these disability claimants off of benefits, they could save loads of money by the correct research and correct treatment of around 250,000 ME patients in the UK alone (1 million in the USA, 20 M worldwide estimated).

click2find

Most popular