Test Valley Borough Council (TVBC) has won a legal battle to protect a unique building in Goodworth Clatford that was the subject of a planning dispute.

DCLI Builders Ltd had placed a patch of tarmac around the village’s water tower, which they intend to convert into a residential unit, without planning permission in 2018. Upon discovering this, TVBC instructed them to remove the tarmac, having advised them that retrospective planning permission was likely to be rejected.

DCLI subsequently applied for planning permission, which was rejected. The decision was confirmed after an appeal to the planning inspectorate, as it breached local planning policies, and were given three months to remove the tarmac.

After this time had elapse, TVBC said that DCLI had “failed to fully comply” with the ruling, leading to the council deciding to prosecute. The day in court arrived last month, with the company fined £400 and made to pay £750 in costs, as well as a £40 victim surcharge. They were also ordered to remove the unauthorised materials.

Planning portfolio holder Councillor Nick Adams-King, said: “Of course we are pleased with the result, but this matter isn’t necessarily about a successful prosecution. We don’t want for matters to come to this, but there were plenty of opportunities for this to have been put right earlier in the process.

“What this is about, is protecting our countryside. This water tower is in miles of beautiful fields and countryside, and works such as this causes considerable harm if it is not done right. I’m grateful for the work of our planning officers, enforcement team and legal service to see this through.”

Goodworth Clatford’s water tower, located on St Peter’s Close adjacent to the church, was constructed in 1936. While not specifically protected under planning and heritage regulations, it is considered “an important landmark feature” by TVBC.

It is specifically noted in the village’s planning statement as something residents hope will be protected if the conservation area in the town is extended.

DCLI Builders Limited were contacted for comment.